Education

Milburn youth employment report leaves Scotland without a blueprint

A UK-wide review by former Labour minister Alan Milburn proposes tax, welfare and education changes to cut youth unemployment, but its detail is largely limited to England, raising questions for Scotland.

By BM Publishers News · 20 November 2026, 09:45

A major review by former Labour minister Alan Milburn has proposed sweeping changes to tax, welfare and education aimed at helping young people into work, but its detail is overwhelmingly focused on England, according to BBC Education.

The report does not mention Scotland until page 93, and only in passing. It is a further 100 pages before Milburn notes that education, skills, health and local government are devolved to Edinburgh, Cardiff and Belfast.

Across the UK, almost one million people aged 16 to 24 are not in education, employment or training (Neet), a rate of 13% according to the Office for National Statistics. Milburn wants to cut this to 5% within a decade.

His proposals include expanding technical education, providing more apprenticeships, better mental health support and creating a "single front door" to support for young people, described as a Youth Opportunity Service. He also proposes lower national insurance costs for those aged 21 to 24 and cash incentives for employers to take on Neets.

Milburn says the UK and devolved governments "should agree common definitions, a shared set of headline outcomes and a regular joint review of progress" and should consider the "further decentralisation or alignment of reserved youth employment support".

Changes in England relating to devolved areas would not apply directly in Scotland. First Minister John Swinney told parliament his government would "consider carefully all of the contents of the Milburn review and relate it to the substantial and effective practices taken forward in Scotland".

Education Secretary Màiri McAllan said that nearly 20 years after the global financial crash, young people in Scotland were struggling in part because of "UK austerity and the economic and social catastrophe of Brexit". She said Scotland would collaborate where there was opportunity, but added that many of the reforms recommended for England reflect approaches Scotland has already embedded.

The Scottish government stresses that 93.6% of 16 to 19-year-olds are participating in education, training or employment, but the absence of data for 20 to 24-year-olds means the figure is of limited use. The Scottish Fiscal Commission has warned of a funding gap for devolved social security spending of £1.2bn by 2030/31.

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation said it was concerned about proposed cuts to disability benefits, which would "reach young disabled people in Scotland too", noting that universal credit remains reserved to Westminster.

Scottish entrepreneur Sir Tom Hunter, who led a similar review in Scotland 20 years ago, criticised Labour for raising employers' national insurance contributions. He suggested the government should pay half a young person's wages for the first two years and exempt them from tax, adding: "My worry is if a young person doesn't catch the work habit early, maybe they'll never catch it."

The report offers politicians across the UK much to consider, but for Scotland, Milburn has not provided a specific blueprint for how to proceed.

Source: BBC Education