Education

Childhood fibs are a sign of healthy mental development, psychologists say

Children who deny eating biscuits or blame the dog are developing a normal mental skill, experts say, and parents can encourage honesty by making it safe to tell the truth.

By BM Publishers News · 20 November 2026, 08:55

Children who deny taking biscuits from the tin or blame the family dog for drawings on the wall are showing a normal part of mental development rather than simply being naughty, according to clinical psychologists.

Speaking on the CBeebies Parenting Download podcast, clinical psychologist Dr Jade Redfern said deception is a skill children are developing and practising. She noted that very young children are not yet sophisticated enough to lie, but are capable of deception before their first birthday.

Research from the University of Bristol cited on the podcast found that about a quarter of children appear to understand some form of deception by the age of 10 months. Prof Elena Hoicka, who led the study, said it was striking how young children could be so adept, describing her own children hiding under the table or in the bathroom to eat sweets.

Hoicka said deception from about the age of two is fairly basic, such as pretending not to hear a parent or denying doing something, and may include doing forbidden things in secret or making excuses like needing the toilet when asked to tidy up.

By three, children become more skilled and creative in their deceptions, showing a deeper grasp of language and how other people think. They may also withhold information, for example truthfully saying a sibling hit them while leaving out that they hit first.

Redfern said such behaviour reflects the development of what she calls "theory of mind", which underpins empathy and the ability to recognise that other people have different thoughts and feelings.

She said another reason children lie is self-preservation, because they do not want to upset or disappoint a parent. "All human beings are driven by attachment," she said, adding that children depend on preserving their relationship with caregivers.

Redfern suggested parents can encourage honesty by creating a safe environment in which a child feels able to admit a mistake without fear of disappointing them.

Rachel Duffy, who won the latest series of The Traitors, told the podcast how her eldest son initially lied after borrowing his brother's bike and breaking it in a crash with a car. She told him he would not get into big trouble for telling the truth and gave him space, after which he admitted it. The conversation that followed involved no raised voices, she said.

Redfern said there are also occasions when a lie or a degree of nuance may be appropriate, such as when a child receives an unwanted gift or comments on someone's appearance. She said open, curious conversations help children develop empathy when empathy has been shown to them repeatedly.

Source: BBC Education