UK minister criticises broadcasters for airing Russell Brand's prison message
Labour deputy leader Lucy Powell says mainstream media should not have amplified a message read on jailed comedian Russell Brand's YouTube channel, prompting a prison rules investigation and a BBC apology.
UK education secretary and Labour deputy leader Lucy Powell has criticised media organisations for carrying a message from the wife of jailed comedian Russell Brand, saying it should not have been given a platform.
Laura Brand read out the message on her husband's YouTube channel on Sunday. In it, he stated he was not guilty of the offences for which he is serving a 10-and-a-half year prison sentence. The message has prompted an official investigation into whether Brand broke prison rules.
The clip was played by outlets including BBC Radio 4's Today programme, ITV's This Morning, Sky News, LBC and the News Agents podcast. Speaking to LBC on Wednesday, Powell said she was appalled by the message and that mainstream media should not have transmitted it.
"It's a platform I don't think should have been amplified, to be honest," she said, describing Brand as someone showing no remorse or sensitivity towards his victims, and noting he had been convicted of very serious offences including rape.
The BBC said the Today programme had played the clip in error due to miscommunication within the team, and had since removed it from its BBC Sounds catch-up service. BBC News has asked the other outlets for comment.
ITN chief executive Ian Rumsey told BBC Radio 4's The Media Show that its newsrooms, including ITV News and Channel 4 News, decided not to show the video, saying it could be discussed and described without being broadcast.
YouTube said it is aware of the video and is investigating. It said Brand's channel has been unable to earn money since being suspended from its advert revenue scheme in 2023 for violating its creator responsibility policy, though the channel remains viewable. His accounts on Meta platforms, which owns Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp, were disabled last week.
Downing Street officials called the message clearly appalling and said it was being urgently investigated, adding that action is expected if Brand is found to have broken prison rules. The prime minister's official spokesman said prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims and may speak to the media only in exceptional circumstances, and cannot avoid these rules by having someone else publish their comments.
Why it matters
The case centres on how broadcasters handle content from convicted offenders and the limits placed on prisoners communicating publicly. It is a media ethics debate in the UK rather than a Zambian matter, but it illustrates how quickly material published online can spread through mainstream outlets.
Source: BBC Entertainment & Arts