Sports

Premier League panel logs joint-record six refereeing errors in one weekend

The Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel found six on-field errors in the latest round of matches, matching its highest tally for a single weekend, though only two were missed VAR interventions.

By BM Publishers News · 19 November 2026, 05:17

The Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel has recorded six on-field refereeing errors in the most recent round of fixtures, a joint-high for a single weekend since it began logging such figures.

Each week the panel's five members review contentious incidents and vote on whether the referee and the video assistant referee (VAR) reached the correct decisions. The last time six mistakes were logged was early in the 2023-24 season. The tally does not include correct VAR interventions that fixed errors, such as the red card shown to Brentford's Igor Thiago.

Almost every match in the round produced a disputed call. Coventry City were not given a penalty for a hair pull by Everton's James Tarkowski, while Arsenal were denied a spot kick after a VAR review found Kai Havertz offside. Tottenham complained about a challenge by Leeds United's Jayden Bogle that brought no red card, and Liverpool disputed a late penalty awarded to Crystal Palace.

Incidents ruled incorrect

  • The panel voted 5-0 that Coventry should have had a penalty when Tarkowski pulled Caleb Yirenkyi's hair, and that VAR should have intervened.
  • It voted 5-0 that Arsenal should have had a penalty for a hold by Hull City's Nobel Mendy on Havertz, despite his offside position, saying the holding came first and was impactful.
  • Everton's opening goal against Coventry, scored by Thierno Barry, was judged incorrect on the field by a 3-2 vote over a possible handball, but the panel voted 5-0 that VAR could not intervene because the footage was not conclusive.
  • Crystal Palace's stoppage-time penalty against Liverpool was ruled incorrect on the field by 5-0, with the panel finding contact was inevitable, but it agreed 5-0 that it was not a clear and obvious error for VAR.
  • Ipswich Town's penalty against Bournemouth was ruled incorrect on the field by a 4-1 vote, but the panel voted 4-1 against a VAR intervention.
  • A possible second yellow card for Bournemouth's Marcus Tavernier was ruled incorrect on the field by a 3-2 vote, with no VAR intervention possible.

Several high-profile decisions were backed. The panel voted 3-2 that Bogle's challenge on Tottenham's Mathys Tel was correctly handled, with the majority finding insufficient force for serious foul play. It voted 4-1 that Chelsea's Cole Palmer should have been awarded a free kick, rather than a penalty, for contact by Sunderland's Luke O'Nien outside the area. It unanimously backed the penalty Sunderland won when Levi Colwill tripped Brian Bobbey, and unanimously cleared Senne Lammens of impactful contact on Aston Villa goalkeeper Zion Suzuki before Patrick Dorgu's 96th-minute equaliser.

The panel's findings feed a merit table that contributes 50% of referees' bonus payments in the Premier League. The equivalent body was scrapped in the Scottish Premiership this summer after clubs grew frustrated with its voting patterns.

The panel assesses decisions against the laws of the game and the league's expected standards of officiating rather than public opinion, which helps explain why only two missed VAR interventions were logged despite the weekend's controversy.

Source: BBC Sport Football