Sports

Cummins faces scrutiny as sandpaper fallout returns to haunt Australia

Former England bowler Jonathan Agnew says Pat Cummins' Australia captaincy is under pressure after fresh claims about the 2018 sandpaper scandal, with the Perth Test against New Zealand set to draw intense attention.

By BM Publishers News · 19 November 2026, 18:34

Pat Cummins' position as Australia captain is under renewed scrutiny following fresh revelations about the 2018 sandpaper controversy in Cape Town, according to BBC Sport columnist Jonathan Agnew.

Agnew, a former bowler, writes that the idea the bowling attack did not know what Cameron Bancroft was doing to the ball has never seemed believable. He argues that the ball belongs to the bowlers, and a batsman would not work on it without their knowledge.

He says players often stay silent while their careers are active, fearing for their futures, and only speak more freely once they retire or believe their international days are over. He adds that suggestions Steve Smith, David Warner and Bancroft have had their guilt reduced by taking responsibility for team-mates do not hold, since Smith was captain, Warner devised the plan and Bancroft carried it out.

Cummins, a junior bowler in the side at the time, has since risen to the captaincy, a role Agnew describes as often joked to be the second most important in Australia. Agnew calls Cummins a credible voice on improving the team's image, though he notes the Jonny Bairstow stumping at Lord's in the 2023 Ashes was a missed chance to prove Australia no longer put winning above everything.

There is no clear indication that Cummins has considered resigning or faces dismissal, and he is due to lead Australia in the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December. Agnew expects the build-up to be dominated by questions about the scandal, with the match played in Bancroft's home city and in the state where his testimony was first published.

Agnew writes that Cummins has said he does not want to discuss sandpaper again, which he calls unrealistic given the media scrutiny and crowd taunting that would await him at next summer's Ashes at Trent Bridge on 18 June. He suggests a possible exit would be resignation without admitting guilt, citing the distraction to the team and pressure on family life, and notes questions remain for others in Cape Town, Cricket Australia and the sport's culture in the country.

Source: BBC Sport